4 Reasons Not to Own a Car

The following post comes to us from Mia. Mia is the founder of Money-Minded Millennial, a personal finance blog that teaches readers how to save and earn more money while consciously designing their ideal life. Visit https://moneymindedmillennial.com/ to get inspired and join the growing tribe of people seeking Financial Independence.

Iโ€™ve never really gotten much joy from driving. I donโ€™t like having to sit still for long periods of time, and I also donโ€™t like the feeling of being dependent on a vehicle to get me places. 

Aside from that, Iโ€™m also a terrible driver. Every car Iโ€™ve ever driven has at least one ding or scratch on it.

When it came time for me to go to college, I chose a school in Boston because the public transportation system would make it so that Iโ€™d never have to own a car. 

That worked out fine, until my husband and I moved to Miami, a largely car-dominated city. It took me a couple months to find a job here, and by the time I accepted an offer we had already signed a short-term lease at an apartment that was 30 minutes away from the office. Since my husband and I shared his car between the two of us, we took turns Ubering to work or coordinating to align our commutes, which got very stressful very fast.

We couldโ€™ve bought an extra car for my use, but given the reasons I listed at the beginning of this article, we decided to stick with sharing his car. When our lease came to an end, we made it a priority to find an apartment that was within walking distance of my job. 

This small change was one of the best decisions Iโ€™ve ever made and convinced me that itโ€™s possible to be a one-car household. Whether your car lease is almost up and youโ€™re thinking of not renewing, or you have an extra car that sits in the garage, these next benefits may give you the push you need to switch to the car-less life.ย 

Cost

Saving money is probably the most obvious benefit of not owning a car. But just how much money does it save you every month to reject car ownership? Hereโ€™s an approximate breakdown:

Car payment: $472ย 

Your biggest car expense is most likely the cost of the car itself. According to the 2019 State of the Automotive Finance Market by Experian, the average monthly payment is $554 for a new vehicle and $391 for a used one. Taking the average car payment amount for new and used vehicles, the average monthly car payment is about $472.

Gas: $200

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the average travel time to work is 26 minutes. Taking into account traffic and a mix of highways and slower roads, we can assume an average commuting speed of 40 miles per hour. Traveling for 26 minutes at 40 mph leads us to an average round-trip commute of about 35 miles.ย 

The cost of gas depends on the fuel efficiency of your car. On average though, the cost of gas is 15 cents per mile. 

Driving 35 miles per day and spending 15 cents per mile means the average cost of gas just on commuting is $5.25 per day, or $157.50 per month. 

Of course, cars arenโ€™t used just for commuting. In a given week, you may use your car to drive to the store, attend events, and maybe take longer-distance road trips. Taking all of this driving into account, youโ€™re probably spending close to $200 per month in gas.

Insurance: $44

According to insure.com, the average annual cost of car insurance in the U.S. is $526, or approximately $44 per month.ย 

Maintenance: $99

The cost of maintaining your car would depend a lot on whether the car was new or used, the mileage, etc. However, according to AAA, the average cost of repairs, maintenance and tires for a new car is $99 per month. 

Total monthly cost of car ownership: $815

The cost of owning a car depends on a variety of factors, including where you live, your commute, and the type of car you drive. However, variables aside, the average cost of car ownership is about $815 per month. 

Even if your car is paid off, which according to Experian Automotive takes about 4-5 years, you can still count on spending $343 per month just on recurring expenses.  

Of course, it wouldnโ€™t hurt to have an extra $815 in the bank each month. Aside from the savings, thereโ€™s the opportunity cost of not being able to invest that extra cash. If you invest those savings into a low-cost index fund such as Vanguard, your money would compound and make the car that much more of a financial burden.ย 

Health

Do you have trouble getting motivated to work out? Having a workout built into your daily routine means you canโ€™t avoid it.

My first year in Miami I walked to work. My second year I switched jobs and biked. Then my office moved, and I was lucky enough to have access to public transportation. All three commute situations necessitated that I exercised in some way to get to work. I found that I arrived at the office and returned home feeling more energized than if I had been sitting in a car instead. 

Not only does walking/biking to work benefit my physical health, but my mental health as well. Having two 15-minute trips of fresh air per day and listening to music or podcasts lets me slow down and take a breather from all of the stress of work and home life. 

On the flip side, being sedentary is one of the worst things for your health. Especially if your commute is 30 minutes or more, everything from your weight, heart health, and posture suffer from extended periods of sitting in a car. Plus, road rage doesnโ€™t help your stress levels.

If you make the switch to a car-less life, you will be investing in your long-term physical and mental health.

Environment

Coronavirus gave us insight into how the environment can benefit from a slowed economy. Scientists report an unprecedented 17% decrease in carbon emissions, partly due to the reduction of cars on the road.ย 

Eliminating just one car from the road contributes to the cumulative effect on the health of our planet and its inhabitants. 

Alternative Transportation

You may be reading this thinking: ok, all these reasons make a great case for not owning a car. But what are my alternatives?

Luckily, there are lots of ways to get from point A to point B without needing to own a car. The options are:

ย ย Public transportation

ย ย Biking

ย ย Walking

ย ย Electric bike

ย ย Electric scooter

ย ย Roller-blading

ย ย Hover boar

ย ย Lyft

ย ย Uber

ย ย Car rental (for longer trips)

While everyoneโ€™s situation is different, there are ways to reduce the number of cars in your household or reject car ownership completely. Maybe youโ€™re changing houses and can consider moving somewhere thatโ€™s more public transportation accessible. Or maybe youโ€™re in between jobs and can choose a job thatโ€™s closer to where you live. Another option is to carpool with a coworker, so you can both save money and the headache of driving every day, as well as reduce your carbon footprint. 

Your car might seem like something thatโ€™s impossible to live without, but if you consider small changes you can make to either reduce the number of cars you have or the amount of time you use your car, your wallet and health will thank you. 

About the Author Jacob A Irwin

Hi folks! My name is Jacob. I am the owner and operator of My Personal Finance Journey. I started this blog in January of 2010 and have enjoyed the journey ever since. Since finishing up graduate school in Virginia in 2014, I have been working in biopharmaceutical development in Colorado. You can read more about me and this site hereโ€‹. Please contact me if you have any questions!

follow me on:
  • Sam Michael says:

    I like the idea but I don’t think it is easy for anyone to implement
    maybe it is good for single person who is not married

    or for a couple with no kids

  • >